| Yoga in Perception and Performance |
|
|
Influence of yoga on mood states, distress, quality of life and immune outcomes in early stage breast cancer patients undergoing surgery
Raghavendra M Rao, Nagendra H R, Nagarathna Raghuram, Vinay C, Chandrashekara S1, Gopinath K S2, Srinath B S
|
ABSTRACT
Context: Breast cancer patients awaiting surgery experience heightened distress that could affect postoperative outcomes.
Aims: The aim of our study was to evaluate the effects of yoga intervention on mood states, treatment-related symptoms,
quality of life and immune outcomes in breast cancer patients undergoing surgery.
Settings and Design: Ninety-eight recently diagnosed stage II and III breast cancer patients were recruited for a randomized
controlled trial comparing the effects of a yoga program with supportive therapy plus exercise rehabilitation on postoperative
outcomes following surgery.
Materials and Methods: Subjects were assessed prior to surgery and four weeks thereafter. Psychometric instruments were
used to assess self-reported anxiety, depression, treatment-related distress and quality of life. Blood samples were collected
for enumeration of T lymphocyte subsets (CD4 %, CD8 % and natural killer (NK) cell % counts) and serum immunoglobulins
(IgG, IgA and IgM).
Statistical Analysis Used: We used analysis of covariance to compare interventions postoperatively.
Results: Sixty-nine patients contributed data to the current analysis (yoga n = 33, control n = 36). The results suggest
a significant decrease in the state (P = 0.04) and trait (P = 0.004) of anxiety, depression (P = 0.01), symptom severity
(P = 0.01), distress (P < 0.01) and improvement in quality of life (P = 0.01) in the yoga group as compared to the controls.
There was also a significantly lesser decrease in CD 56% (P = 0.02) and lower levels of serum IgA (P = 0.001) in the yoga
group as compared to controls following surgery.
Conclusions: The results suggest possible benefi ts for yoga in reducing postoperative distress and preventing immune
suppression following surgery.
|
Key words: Cancer; immunity; mood; surgery; yoga
|
Awaiting surgery is a distressing experience for most
breast cancer patients.[1-3] It has been described as a acute,
short-term stressor with multiple stressful components
such as concerns regarding ones physical condition,
postoperative recovery, hospital admissions, anticipating
painful procedures, image problems, confronting cancer
diagnosis and worries about survival and recovery.[4] It is
known that such concerns evoke strong emotional and
psychological reactions in the subjects further heightening
preoperative distress. Such heightened preoperative
distress has been found to be related to longer hospital
stays, delayed recovery, more postoperative complications,
pain and increased need for medications.[4,5] These
distressing symptoms are also known to impair local and
systemic immune responses leading to delayed wound
repair[6,7] and postoperative infections.[8,9] Apart from
direct effects on endocrine and immune function, greater
pain sensitivity and distress of more anxious patients
may affect recovery because of reduced compliance; for
example, breathing exercises reduce the risk of pneumonia
following surgery.[10] Patients may become more cautious
about following recommendations for walking, breathing or coughing because of pain and distress further affecting
the process of recovery.[5]
A multitude of factors seem to affect antitumor and innate
immune responses collectively during surgical recovery
such as mood, perceived stress, anti-inflammatory
analgesics and anesthesia. Medications that reduce
pain and distress such as analgesics,[11] corticosteroids,
morphine[12] and anesthetics[13,14] following surgery can
directly help reduce treatment-related distress, improve
functional well being and reduce consequent immune
suppression. However, such medications are not
always cost-effective and have side effects ranging from
gastrointestinal distress, nausea and, sleep disturbances[10]
and also excessive use can dampen both innate and
anti-tumor immune responses.[4] For example, marked
suppression of NK cell activity and count is observed
following surgical procedures that often last for an
extended period inspite of the use of anti-inflammatory
and anesthetic medications.[15] This transitory dysfunction
of NK cells may create a favourable milieu for metastases.
This has been attributed to loss of control over dormant
micrometastases or from an inability to destroy tumor cells
released perioperatively.[16] Moreover, changes in NK cell
activity and number seem to be affected by mood states
with decreased NK cell numbers seen with depressed
mood[17,18] and decreased NK cell activity is related to
anxiety states.[19]
There is evidence to show that interventions that alter
appraisal, coping and/or mood may also modulate
immune and endocrine function, thereby enhancing
surgical recovery.[20,21] Even modest interventions that
have relatively small consequences for psychological
distress such as educating the patient about surgery[22]
and improving the ambience in the wards[23] are known
to influence the recovery process. Several meta-analyses
of presurgical intervention studies have argued that
association between presurgical intervention and clinical
outcome is clinically meaningful.[24] Depending on the
meta-analysis, two thirds to three quarters of intervention
patients had better outcomes than control subjects with
the size of improvement ranging from 2028%.[24] These
stress reduction and behavioral interventions apart from
reducing distress, are also known to affect immune
responses in general.[25,26]
Yoga is one such psychotherapeutic intervention,
which, has been used effectively in numerous health
care conditions where stress was believed to play a role.
General effects of yoga in promoting health are due
to its ability to establish stable autonomic balance,[27]
development of hypometabolic states,[28] improvement of
physical efficiency,[29] improvement of thermoregulatory efficiency,[30] increase in cardiopulmory functions,[31]
improved immunological tolerance,[32] neuro-endocronine
functions,[33-35] improved mood states[36-38] and a tranquil
state of mind to combat stress.[39] These physiological
benefits possibly explain the rationale for using yoga
intervention to reduce distress and improve immune
outcomes in cancer subjects undergoing surgery. Moreover,
various techniques of yoga have shown to improve mood
states, reduce stress, improve quality of life and, adjustment
in cancer patients.[40] In an earlier study, we have shown
yoga to reduce treatment-related distress and symptoms in
breast cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy.[41] This
may have implications in the current context wherein
high psychological distress is seen preoperatively. We
hypothesize that yoga interventions would help reduce
psychological distress and improve anti-tumor immune
responses in breast cancer patients following surgery.
|
|
|
You do not have permission to sell or distribute or reproduce
Research @ SVYASA Papers text or any portion of the text in any form (printed, electronic or otherwise). To do so is a violation of copyright law
|
|
|
Research
Contributions of
SVYASA
(2 Volumes)
PRINT EDITION
US $ 33.00 Write to svyasa@svyasa.org |
|