|
|
|
A Randomized Control Trial of the Effect of Yoga on Gunas (Personality) and Health in Normal Healthy Volunteers
|
Sudheer Deshpande, Nagendra H R, Raghuram Nagarathna
|
ABSTRACT
|
Objective: To study the efficacy of yoga on Guna (yogic personality measure) and general health in normal adults.
Methods: Of the 1228 persons who attended introductory lectures, 226 subjects aged 18–71 years, of both sexes, who satisfied
the inclusion and exclusion criteria and who consented to participate in the study were randomly allocated into two groups.
The Yoga(Y) group practised an integrated yoga module that included asanas, pranayama, meditation, notional correction
and devotional sessions. The control group practised mild to moderate physical exercises (PE). Both groups had supervised
practice sessions (by trained experts) for one hour daily, six days a week for eight weeks. Guna (yogic personality) was
assessed before and after eight weeks using the self-administered Vedic Personality Inventory (VPI) which assesses Sattva
(gentle and controlled), Rajas (violent and uncontrolled) and Tamas (dull and uncontrolled).
The general health status (total health), which includes four domains namely somatic symptoms (SS), anxiety and insomnia
(AI), social dysfunction (SF) and severe depression (SP), was assessed using a General Health Questionnaire (GHQ).
Results: Baseline scores for all the domains for both the groups did not differ signifi cantly (P > 0.05, independent samples
t test). Sattva showed a signifi cant difference within the groups and the effect size was more in the Y than in the PE group.
Rajas showed a signifi cant decrease within and between the groups with a higher effect size in the PE group. Tamas showed
signifi cant reduction within the PE group only. The GHQ revealed that there was signifi cant decrease in SS, AI, SF and SP in
both Y and PE groups (Wilcoxcon Singed Rank t test). SS showed a significant difference between the groups (Mann Whitney
U Test).
Conclusions: There was an improvement in Sattva in both the Yoga and control groups with a trend of higher effect size in
Yoga; Rajas reduced in both but signifi cantly better in PE than in Yoga and Tamas reduced in PE. The general health status
improved in both the Yoga and control groups.
|
Keywords: General health; guna; Yoga.
|
The present age of speed and competition has increased
the stresses and strains resulting in an increasing
prevalence of life style-related health problems.[1] One
of the increasingly popular tools to overcome this new
challenge is physical activity. There is growing evidence
that has established the benefits of physical exercises in
preventing life style-related diseases[2] such as primary
prevention of diabetes,[3] prevention of cardiac diseases
through control over major risk factors such as smoking,
lipids, obesity and stress,[4] better quality of life of cancer
patients,[5] positive health in normal persons through
better physical fitness[6] and stress reduction.[7] Yoga
which is considered to be a tool for both physical and
mental development of an individual is being recognized
around the globe only in the last century although it has
been practised in India over several centuries to promote
positive health and well being. It gives solace for the
restless mind and can give great relief to the sick.[8,9] It has
become quite fashionable even for the common man to keep
fit.[10] Some use yoga for developing memory, intelligence
and creativity.[11] With its multifold advantages, yoga is
becoming a part of school education.[12] Specialists use
it to unfold deeper layers of consciousness in their move
towards spiritual perfection.[13] With growing scientific
evidence, yoga is emerging as an important health
behavior-modifying practice to achieve states of health,
both at physical and mental levels. Several studies have
demonstrated the beneficial effects of yoga on health
behavior in many life style-related somatic problems
such as hypertension,[14] bronchial asthma,[15] diabetes[16]
including some psychiatric conditions such as anxiety
neurosis[17] and depressive illness[18] etc.
The philosophy of yoga believes that somatic problems are
nothing but a manifestation of an imbalance between three
Gunas (Sattva, Rajas and Tamas) that go to constitute the
body-mind complex of the individual.[19] Further, in the
famous scriptural text, the Gita; a guna indicates a specific
behavior style. Sattva is symbolized by purity, wisdom,
bliss, serenity, love of knowledge, spiritual excellence and
other noble and sublime qualities. Rajas is symbolized
by egoism, activity, restlessness and hankering after
mundane things like wealth, power, valor and comforts.
Tamas is related to qualities such as bias, heedlessness
and inertia, perversion in taste, thought and action.[20] Ill
health occurs if Rajas or Tamas become dominant and
the individual gets habituated to either of these response
patterns. Furthermore, the Gita goes on to analyze the
state of mind and says that when one is dominated by
these two gunas, the individual loses mastery over the
uncontrolled, speeded-up loop of sentences of the internal
dialogue, which shows up as upsurges of emotions and
impulsive behavior. In an ideal state of perfect health,
man has the complete freedom to use any of these three
patterns (Satva, Rajas or Tamas) of responses. Hence,
the degree of positive health can be measured by a tool
that can grade these three patterns of behavior.[19] The
tool can be used for assessment of interventions used for
treatment or prevention of diseases as well as for promotion
of positive health. The Vedic Personality Inventory
(VPI)[21] is a valid and reliable inventory that can measure
the three patterns of behavior.
While Yoga is getting popular, the relative roles of yoga
and physical exercises have not been studied on gunas
and health. Hence, the present study was designed to
assess the changes in the personality and overall health
status after yoga as compared to physical exercise
in a randomized controlled study in normal healthy
volunteers.
|
|
|
You do not have permission to sell or distribute or reproduce
Research @ SVYASA Papers text or any portion of the text in any form (printed, electronic or otherwise). To do so is a violation of copyright law
|
|
|
Research
Contributions of
SVYASA
(2 Volumes)
PRINT EDITION
US $ 33.00 Write to svyasa@svyasa.org |
|